One Of Them Days: Honest Squabble Review

Nextgenwave

You need 4 min read

·

Post on Jan 20, 2025

40 visitor like this post

Share

One of Them Days: An Honest Squabble Review

One of Them Days isn't just a game; it's a meticulously crafted experience designed to test the mettle of even the most seasoned board game enthusiasts. This isn't your typical family-friendly affair; it's a cutthroat battle of wits, strategy, and (let's be honest) a little bit of luck. This review dives deep into the mechanics, the experience, and ultimately, whether One of Them Days lives up to the hype.

Gameplay: A Masterclass in Chaos and Control

At its core, One of Them Days is a worker placement game with a compelling narrative twist. Players take on the roles of rival families vying for control of a burgeoning city. Each round represents a "day," and players strategically allocate their family members (workers) to various locations across the city to collect resources, build structures, and ultimately, score victory points.

Worker Placement with a Punch:

The worker placement mechanism is elegantly implemented. The game board itself is a beautifully illustrated representation of the city, with various locations offering unique actions and rewards. This isn't a simple "pick a spot and take the action" system though. Locations often have limited spaces, creating intense competition and forcing players to adapt their strategies on the fly. The tension is palpable as you watch your opponents claim the prime spots, leaving you scrambling for less desirable options.

Resource Management: The Backbone of Success:

Resource management forms the very backbone of One of Them Days. Players need to carefully balance their acquisition of resources with their spending, ensuring they have enough to fund their expansion and outmaneuver their opponents. Running out of crucial resources at a critical moment can be utterly devastating, emphasizing the importance of forethought and careful planning. The variety of resources – from lumber and stone to more unique items – adds another layer of complexity and strategic depth.

Events & Intrigue: The Unexpected Twist:

One of Them Days isn't just about efficient resource management. The game throws in a handful of unexpected events and challenges, represented by cards drawn throughout the game. These events can drastically alter the game's trajectory, forcing players to react quickly and adjust their plans accordingly. This element introduces a fascinating blend of luck and adaptation, ensuring that no two games play out exactly the same. This unpredictability prevents the game from becoming stale, even after multiple playthroughs.

Family Dynamics: A Narrative Hook:

The family members themselves aren't just faceless workers; they have unique abilities and characteristics, adding a personal touch to the gameplay. Choosing the right family member for the right task can often be the key to success. This strategic element adds a deeper layer of engagement, encouraging players to think carefully about how they utilize their family's resources and skills.

Production Quality: A Feast for the Senses:

One of Them Days boasts impressive production quality. The game components are beautifully crafted, from the sturdy game board and richly illustrated cards to the detailed family member meeples. The artwork is stunning, contributing significantly to the overall immersive experience. Everything feels substantial and luxurious, further enhancing the enjoyment of the gameplay.

Replayability: A Game That Keeps Giving:

One of Them Days offers remarkably high replayability. The variable setup, combined with the unpredictable nature of the event cards, ensures that each game feels fresh and engaging. The strategic depth allows for numerous approaches, and even experienced players will discover new strategies and tactics with each playthrough. This makes it a game that will keep you coming back for more.

Target Audience and Recommended Player Count:

One of Them Days is best suited for experienced board game players who enjoy strategic depth and cutthroat competition. It's not a game for casual players seeking a lighthearted experience. The optimal player count is 2-4, with the complexity scaling appropriately as the player count increases. However, even with fewer players the strategic tension remains.

Strengths and Weaknesses:

Strengths:

• Strategic Depth: The complex interplay of worker placement, resource management, and event cards creates a challenging and rewarding experience.
• Immersive Theme: The well-developed theme and beautiful components enhance the overall gameplay experience.
• High Replayability: The variable setup and unpredictable events ensure that each game is unique and engaging.
• Excellent Production Quality: The game components are of exceptionally high quality.

Weaknesses:

• High Complexity: The game's complexity may be off-putting to casual players.
• Game Length: One of Them Days can take a significant amount of time to complete.

Final Verdict:

One of Them Days is a phenomenal board game that delivers a truly exceptional experience for those willing to invest the time and effort. Its strategic depth, immersive theme, and high production quality combine to create a game that is as challenging as it is rewarding. While its complexity may not be for everyone, for experienced board game enthusiasts seeking a stimulating and engaging experience, One of Them Days is a must-have. The careful balancing of luck and strategic gameplay keeps it fresh and thrilling, creating a truly memorable and competitive game night. Despite its complexity, the rewarding nature of the gameplay far outweighs any potential drawbacks. It's a game that demands your full attention, and it generously repays you with a highly satisfying and deeply engaging experience. The squabbles are worth it.