Patriots' McDaniels Hiring: 9 Winners & Losers

Nextgenwave

You need 4 min read

·

Post on Jan 26, 2025

46 visitor like this post

Share

Patriots' McDaniels Hiring: 9 Winners & Losers

The New England Patriots' hiring of Bill O'Brien as offensive coordinator sent shockwaves through the NFL. While the move itself might seem straightforward, the ripple effects are significant, creating a clear list of winners and losers within the Patriots organization and beyond. This analysis delves into the implications of this pivotal decision, examining nine key figures impacted by the appointment.

The Winners

1. Bill O'Brien: This is the most obvious win. After a tumultuous stint with the Houston Texans and a less-than-successful return to college football at Alabama, O'Brien has a chance to revitalize his NFL coaching career. The Patriots, despite their recent offensive struggles, provide a stable and well-resourced environment. Success here could catapult him back into head coaching contention. Furthermore, working with Mac Jones, a quarterback with demonstrable potential, offers a compelling opportunity to showcase his offensive prowess and coaching acumen. This is a high-stakes gamble, but the potential rewards are immense for O'Brien.

2. Mac Jones: Jones's sophomore season was a disappointment, largely attributed to the offensive struggles and coaching inconsistencies. O'Brien's arrival brings hope for a revitalized offensive system better suited to Jones's strengths. O'Brien has a proven track record of developing quarterbacks, suggesting Jones could flourish under his tutelage. The change offers a clean slate, a chance to rebuild confidence and prove his worth as an NFL starting quarterback. The success of this pairing is crucial for both of their futures.

3. Robert Kraft: The Patriots owner has been vocal about his desire to return to Super Bowl contention. The hiring of O'Brien represents a significant investment in improving the team's offensive performance. O'Brien's experience and reputation could provide the necessary stability and expertise to unlock the team's offensive potential. A successful O'Brien-led offense translates directly into increased ticket sales, merchandise revenue, and overall franchise value for Kraft.

4. Patriots Offensive Players: The Patriots' offensive players, particularly the skill position players, stand to benefit from O'Brien's arrival. A more structured and effective offensive scheme could lead to more opportunities and increased production. Players like Rhamondre Stevenson and Jakobi Meyers will likely see their roles redefined and optimized within O'Brien's system, potentially boosting their individual performances and market value. The improved offensive flow will alleviate some pressure from the defense, allowing them to perform more effectively.

5. NFL Offensive Coordinators: While seemingly paradoxical, the success of O'Brien in New England could indirectly benefit other offensive coordinators. If O'Brien revives his career and achieves significant offensive success with the Patriots, it reaffirms the importance of strong offensive coaching, raising the profile and potential compensation for other offensive coordinators across the league.

The Losers

6. Matt Patricia and Joe Judge: The dual experiment of having Patricia and Judge coordinate the offense in 2022 was widely panned as a colossal failure. Their departures, though not explicitly because of O'Brien's arrival, represent a clear admission of that failure. Their careers have taken a significant hit, and their reputations have suffered from their involvement in this unsuccessful offensive strategy. Finding future employment at a comparable level will likely be challenging.

7. Alternative Offensive Coordinator Candidates: The hiring of O'Brien closes the door on other potential candidates for the Patriots offensive coordinator position. These individuals, who might have brought their own innovative schemes and coaching philosophies, are now left to pursue other opportunities. The competition for top offensive coordinator positions is fierce, and this missed chance represents a setback for those who were hoping to join the Patriots.

8. The "Offensive Line by Committee" Approach: The Patriots' inconsistent offensive line play in recent seasons has been a major point of concern. While O'Brien's arrival doesn't directly address this issue, his offensive system might place greater emphasis on certain line skills, potentially impacting player usage and development. Players who excel in a different scheme might find themselves less relevant under O'Brien's leadership. This makes the success of the offensive line even more critical for the overall offensive strategy.

9. The "Spread Offense" Advocates within the Patriots Organization: While O'Brien is not known as a staunch proponent of the spread offense, he is adaptable. If he chooses to implement a more traditional pro-style offense, this could represent a setback for those within the organization who advocated for a more modern, spread-based offensive approach. This internal power dynamic shift could impact future offensive strategies and personnel decisions.

Conclusion: A High-Stakes Gamble with Far-Reaching Consequences

The hiring of Bill O'Brien by the New England Patriots is far more than just a coaching change. It's a high-stakes gamble with potential benefits and drawbacks rippling across the organization and the broader NFL landscape. The success or failure of this decision will define not only the 2023 season but also the long-term trajectories of several key individuals and potentially the future direction of the Patriots' franchise. Time will tell if this was a masterstroke or a missed opportunity, but the ramifications are already being felt. The coming season will offer a crucial evaluation of this pivotal decision and its impact on all stakeholders.